The Employer Retirement Plans, Explained

Ask an employee what they have at work and the answer is usually "a pension." Ask what kind and the answer is usually a pause. That pause is not ignorance. Four very different arrangements share one word in ordinary speech, and the difference between them only becomes visible on the day somebody leaves.

The defined benefit plan: a promise of income

This is the arrangement most people picture when they hear the word pension, and it is the one becoming least common.

The plan promises an income, calculated by a formula written into the plan text. Years of service and a measure of earnings usually appear in that formula, and the result is a monthly amount rather than a balance.

What matters about that structure is who carries the risk. If the investments do poorly, the promise does not change. If a member lives far longer than expected, the promise does not change. Both of those risks sit with the plan and, behind it, with the employer.

That is also why these plans are expensive to run and why fewer employers offer them than a generation ago. The promise is real, and somebody has to be able to keep it.

For a member, the important documents are the plan text and the annual statement, and the important question on leaving is what options exist for the value: leaving it in the plan, transferring it out, or taking a deferred pension. Those options are set by the plan and by the legislation governing it.

The defined contribution plan: a promise of contributions

This plan promises what goes in, not what comes out, and the whole difference lives in that sentence.

The employer contributes, often matching what the member contributes, according to a formula in the plan. The money is invested among the choices the plan offers, and at retirement the member has whatever the account grew to.

The investment risk sits with the member. So does the question of what to do with the balance at the end, which is where the locked in accounts in the companion article on this site come from.

None of that makes it a worse plan. It makes it a different plan, with the risk in a different place, and a member who thinks they hold a promise of income when they hold a promise of contributions is planning on a picture that is not theirs.

The question to ask, and it takes one sentence to the plan administrator, is this: does my plan promise an income, or does it promise contributions.

The group RRSP, which is not a pension plan

A group RRSP is exactly what its name says: individual RRSPs, opened for employees and administered together, usually with payroll deduction and often with an employer contribution.

The advantages are real. Deductions happen at source, so the tax relief arrives with each pay rather than at the end of the year, and the administration costs of a group arrangement are usually lower than a person would pay alone.

What it is not is a pension plan. It is not governed by pension legislation, and the money in it is generally not locked in the way pension money is. A member who leaves usually takes an ordinary RRSP with them.

That flexibility cuts in both directions, and this is the part worth being honest about. Money that can be withdrawn is money that sometimes is, and a plan meant for retirement that gets used for a renovation has done what the rules allowed and not what it was for.

Some group arrangements add a deferred profit sharing plan for the employer contributions, which behaves differently again. If a booklet mentions one, the booklet is the place to read what it does.

The Quebec obligation, and the three ways out of it

Quebec did something most provinces did not. It put an obligation on the employer, and it wrote the threshold into legislation.

The Voluntary Retirement Savings Plans Act provides that any employer who, on December 31 of a given year, employs five eligible employees or more must, in the year that follows, subscribe to a voluntary retirement savings plan.

Eligible employee has a definition and all three parts count. At least eighteen years old. An employee under the labour standards legislation working in Quebec. And credited with one year of uninterrupted service.

So the count is not a headcount. A business with a dozen people can be below the threshold, and a business with five long serving employees can be above it.

The Act also sets out where the obligation does not apply: where the employer allows employees to contribute by payroll deduction to a designated registered retirement savings plan or a designated tax free savings account, or where the employees benefit from a registered pension plan to which the employer is a party.

That is the sentence a small employer should read carefully, because it means the obligation is to offer access to something, not necessarily to subscribe to this particular thing.

Inside the VRSP: automatic enrolment, sixty days, and locked in employer money

Three features of this plan are worth knowing by an employee and by the owner who has to set one up.

Enrolment is automatic. A worker is enrolled unless they decline, which is the opposite of how most savings arrangements work and is the reason these plans reach people who would otherwise never start.

Declining has a deadline. Retraite Quebec states that the worker must notify the employer that they will not enrol within sixty days following the date on which the administrator sent the statement of participation. After that period, the worker is enrolled.

And employer contributions are locked in. Retraite Quebec states that they are protected and cannot be withdrawn before age fifty five.

That last point matters in both directions. For the employee it means employer money is retirement money and not emergency money. For the owner it means a contribution is a long commitment to the employee rather than a bonus by another name.

Whether the employer contributes at all is a separate question from the obligation to subscribe, and it is a business decision rather than a rule. This article does not state it as one.

What happens when the employment ends, which is where the differences appear

Every distinction above is invisible until the last day, and then all of them arrive at once.

Pension money generally leaves as locked in money, into a locked in retirement account, with the rules of whichever legislation governs the plan. A locked in VRSP account is among the sources Retraite Quebec lists as transferable into a locked in retirement account.

Group RRSP money generally leaves as ordinary RRSP money.

The group insurance, which usually sits in the same booklet and is a different subject entirely, generally ends with the employment, and the window to convert it to an individual contract without new medical questions is short and is written in the booklet.

That is the practical reason to read the booklet while still employed rather than after. Three different deadlines can run from the same last day, and nobody sends a reminder about any of them.

Where to read this at the source

The employer obligation, the five eligible employee threshold, the definition of an eligible employee and the exemptions are set out in the Voluntary Retirement Savings Plans Act, published by the Government of Quebec. Automatic enrolment, the sixty day period to decline and the locking in of employer contributions are published by Retraite Quebec, as are the sources that can be transferred into a locked in retirement account.

Read on 24 September 2026, free to consult, and subject to revision without notice. No rate, limit or amount is printed in this article, and no plan text was read for it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Continue Learning

What the retirement money becomes on leaving is set out in the LIRA and the LIF, the individual plan a group RRSP resembles in the RRSP explained, and the public plan underneath every one of them in the Quebec Pension Plan explained.